Navigating your business through the PCI ROC process

Ensuring PCI ROC compliance is paramount for merchants handling cardholder data. If your goal is to decipher the PCI ROC process or to verify if your organization requires it, look no further. This blog post will demystify the requirements

Key takeaways

• The PCI Report on Compliance (ROC) is a formal document verifying an organization’s adherence to PCI DSS standards and serves to evaluate an organization’s security controls for cardholder data protection.
• The requirement for a PCI ROC is not universal; it primarily applies to Level 1 merchants handling over 6 million transactions annually and organizations post-data breach, while other levels often use SAQs for compliance validation.
• Maintaining PCI DSS compliance is an ongoing process that extends beyond the annual audit and requires continuous security practices, regular updates to security policies, risk analyses, and a proactive incident response plan in the event of data breaches.

What is the PCI Report on Compliance (ROC)?

The PCI ROC is a formal document that proves an organization’s adherence to PCI DSS standards. From a broader perspective, the PCI ROC is like a report card for merchants and service providers, detailing how they handle cardholder data protection.

Yet, the scope of the PCI ROC extends past simple compliance. It’s a comprehensive account of an organization’s security controls, revealing the strengths and weaknesses in cardholder data protection. As such, it supports the establishment of secure environments, guarding cardholder data against breaches.

Who requires a Report on Compliance?

A PCI ROC is not mandatory for all organizations. Generally, Level 1 merchants and service providers, processing over 6 million Visa or Mastercard transactions per year, are mandated to complete a PCI DSS ROC. While some Level 2 merchants may also need to have a ROC, lower levels typically do not.

However, annual validation of PCI compliance is mandatory, irrespective of transaction volume. Whether it’s a Report on Compliance (ROC) or a Self-Assessment Questionnaire (SAQ), maintaining compliance is a shared responsibility between organizations of all sizes. 

It’s also important to note that a company must undergo a ROC if they experience a cardholder data breach, irrespective of their merchant level, including credit card transactions.

Merchants and Service Providers

Within PCI DSS, merchants are defined by their annual transaction volume, while service providers are considered any business entity that facilitates the transmission, storage, or processing of payment card data. As the volume of transactions a merchant or service provider processes increases, so does the stringency of the assessment criteria and methodology. The four levels are:

Level 1: Service providers or merchants that process over 6 million card transactions annually.

Level 2: Service providers or merchants that process 1 to 6 million transactions annually.

Level 3: Service providers or merchants that process 20,000 to 1 million transactions annually.

Level 4: Service providers or merchants that process fewer than 20,000 transactions annually.

Determining your PCI compliance level is a crucial step in understanding your organization’s specific requirements and the assessment process.

Anatomy of a PCI ROC

The PCI ROC begins with an executive summary that provides an overview of: 

• The assessment
• The company’s environment
• The compliance status

It then details the scope of the assessment, specifying the systems, processes, and facilities included in the audit.

Within the PCI ROC, the detailed findings offer a thorough analysis of the organization’s security measures. It covers everything from firewall configurations and data encryption to the deployment of anti-virus software and the creation of secure systems. 

The report also assesses the frequency and thoroughness of security systems and processes testing, highlighting the organization’s dedication to the ongoing security of cardholder data.

Understanding the relationship Between AoC and RoC

The PCI ROC serves as a detailed report necessary for Level 1 merchants, while the Attestation of Compliance (AOC) acts as a documented confirmation of an organization’s compliance with PCI DSS standards. It is completed after filling out the ROC. The AoC serves to confirm that an organization has undergone its ROC Level 1 and validates its compliance with the PCI DSS requirements.

---

However, the AoC and RoC are not mutually exclusive. An RoC is specifically required for Level 1 merchants and includes validation of a completed ROC/AOC. An SAQ and a PCI assessment verified by a QSA are not included in the validation. 

Your step-by-step guide to completing your PCI ROC

Initiating the process to acquire a PCI ROC can seem overwhelming, but it becomes more manageable with a clearly defined path. The process involves an on-site review by a Qualified Security Assessor (QSA) who rigorously evaluates an organization’s security policies, procedures, and controls related to cardholder data.

While the process may be challenging, it ultimately improves an organization’s security practices.

Selecting a Qualified Security Assessor (QSA)

Selecting a QSA is a significant step in the audit and assessment steps of the ROC process. The QSA should have:

• Substantial experience in assessing security needs similar to those of your organization to effectively address potential security risks, including the expertise of an internal security assessor
• Undergone rigorous training to understand PCI DSS
• Possess adequate credentials for assessing data security

In addition to professional certifications such as CISSP or CISA, the QSA should understand your business model and payment processing environment. A QSA with a track record of success in environments similar to yours and who provides pre-audit questionnaires or checklists will be a valuable ally in your compliance journey.

The audit process

At the heart of the PCI DSS compliance journey is the PCI DSS audit process, which includes a crucial PCI DSS assessment. It encompasses:

• Interviews
• Evidence collection
• Technical and operational evaluation

Organizations can prepare for this process by performing a self-assessment to identify security gaps and maintaining accurate network diagrams to show interactions with card data, ultimately aiming to protect cardholder data.

Typically spanning three to four weeks, the QSA assessment allows for a thorough review and analysis of the cardholder data environment. Upon completion, the QSA fills out the Report on Compliance, and provides an Attestation of Compliance.

Post-assessment actions

Although obtaining the PCI DSS RoC is a significant achievement, it doesn’t mark the end of the process. Post-assessment actions entail the following:

• If the client receives a compliant ROC, they:
  • needs to maintain all controls 
• must continue to perform vulnerability scans, logs, firewall and access reviews, etc. (referred to as Business as Usual or BAU)
• If the client receives a non-compliant ROC, the client must:
  •  Rectify any compliance deficiencies identified in the RoC
  • Implement corrective actions advised by the QSA
  • Create a strategic action plan to address the RoC’s findings
  • Execute necessary remediation measures to ensure sustained PCI DSS adherence.

Regular consultations with the QSA post-assessment are valuable for discussing remedial progress, obtaining additional guidance, and attaining clarifications on the RoC’s outcomes. Transparency in communication regarding the PCI compliance situation and the adaptations required by the QSA’s findings is also crucial.

Maintaining compliance: Year-round best practices

Adherence to PCI DSS isn’t a one-time accomplishment but an ongoing effort. It requires managing controls effectively throughout the year, not just when the annual audit rolls around. A continuous security mentality within the organization helps keep security best practices and controls current and effective.

Having a dedicated compliance leader or team, including representatives from various departments, can facilitate effective management of the PCI compliance process. 

It’s also crucial to perform targeted risk analyses on a regular schedule as well as upon any major changes to business processes involving payment card data. Regularly updating and reviewing PCI DSS scope documentation and security training programs to include recent threats and vulnerabilities also aids in maintaining compliance.

Preparing for potential data breaches

The PCI ROC is instrumental in preparing for potential data breaches. It ensures that a merchant has a comprehensive incident response plan, which is integral for responding to data breaches and minimizing potential liabilities. 

Following a breach, non-compliance with PCI standards can lead to serious repercussions such as penalties, card re-issuance costs, and additional fines based on the volume of compromised card numbers.

• An effective incident response plan includes:
• Preserving evidence to facilitate the identification of compromise indicators
• A detailed communication strategy for engaging with necessary parties post-breach
• Engaging a PCI Forensic Investigator as part of the incident response plans set out by the PCI ROC enables expert analysis and remediation efforts during and after a data breach

Navigating changes in PCI DSS versions

Staying abreast of the most recent PCI DSS standards, as established by the PCI Security Standards Council, is key for compliance maintenance, including meeting the PCI DSS compliance requirements. 

The latest PCI DSS version, PCI DSS v4.0, released on March 31, 2022, introduces changes focused on:

• Continuous security
• Flexibility in maintaining payment security
• The implementation of a customized approach for meeting requirements
• New measures to combat threats such as phishing and e-skimming.

There is a transition period from PCI DSS v3.2.1 to v4.0 until March 31, 2024, allowing organizations ample time to adapt to the new standards and securely transmit cardholder data. 

Updates in authentication controls, such as the implementation of multi-factor authentication for all access to the cardholder data environment and an increase in minimum password length from 8 to 12 characters, are some of the changes in PCI DSS v4.0 aimed at better protecting credit card data.

Resources and support for achieving PCI compliance

Utilizing appropriate tools can simplify compliance and aid in audit self-assessment and remediation initiatives. 

To learn more about PCI DSS compliance, check out these useful posts:

• PCI DSS compliance checklist: The 12 requirements
• Consequences of non-compliance: Uncovering PCI DSS fines and penalties
• Understanding PCI DSS encryption requirements in 2024
• PCI DSS attestation of compliance

Foster trust through PCI DSS compliance with Thoropass

PCI Data Security Standards (PCI DSS) is required for any businesses that process, store, or transmit credit cards and is enforced by the Card Brands and Acquiring Banks. Thoropass streamlines and accelerates your certification by combining automation with self-assessment support and expert insights. Get certified faster with less work and headaches.

More FAQs

---